: Buffy The Vampire Slayer & Angel The Series News Articles
« Close Your Eyes | Main | The Freshman »

June 22, 2004
Two Slayers and a Mayor
by Daniel Erenberg

Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Season Three

Buffy 3.1: “Anne”, written and directed by Joss Whedon

This was an odd, schizophrenic start to a tight and well-strung season. We begin with Buffy in LA doing everything she can to not fight demons. We’re reintroduced to a minor character from season two’s “Lie To Me”, and the rest of the gang fight demons to rather comedic effect back in Sunnydale. It’s a dark and rather uncomfortable episode, in many ways a precursor to Angel or season six of Buffy. I like it.

Buffy 3.2: “Dead Man’s Party”, written by Marti Noxon and directed by James Whitmore Jr.

This is often overlooked because of the rather silly zombie subplot, but it does contain one of the great Scooby conflict scenes, a precursor to stuff like “The Yoko Factor” or “Entropy” or even “Empty Places” in season seven. Noxon’s always been better at character pieces than monster stuff, which isn’t a bad thing. This was a big influence on season six where the major villains were very much human. And where emotion was what ran rampant.

Buffy 3.3: “Faith, Hope, and Trick”, written by David Greenwalt and directed by James A. Contner

This is the beautiful start to the seasonal arc of year three. We are introduced to Scott Hope, the new (short-lived) love interest for Buffy, Mr. Trick, a wonderfully flashy new vampire nemesis, and most importantly the incredible Faith who gels with the cast instantly and shows darker hints at some demons lying within her heavenly frame.

Buffy 3.4: “Beauty and the Beasts”, written by Marti Noxon and directed by James Whitmore, Jr.

This is one of the big disappointments of the year. After the major cliffhanger last week, a big one was expected, but we instead got this rather weak outing. From the pretentious opening voiceover to the forced-feeling conflict and wholly uninteresting Jekyll/Hyde monster of the week subplot, it was just an all around weak outing.

Buffy 3.5: “Homecoming”, written and directed by David Greenwalt

This is the kind of episode that we weren’t allowed to see by the end of the show: just an all-out hilarious episode with no real metaphor or underlying darkness. Just some good old funny. The closest thing to an episode like this in later Buffy was “Him” in season seven, but nothing can touch Greenwalt’s glorious vision of high school rivalry.

Buffy 3.6: “Band Candy”, written by Jane Espenson and directed by Michael Lange

This is Magic Jane’s first episode, and it feels rather like a sitcom. Which could have gotten old fast, but Jane grew as a writer in later years. As for this one, it’s funny, particularly the Mayor who dazzles for the second week in a row.

Buffy 3.7: “Revelations”, written by Douglas Petrie and directed by James A. Contner

This is a highly charged episode and the writing debut of the great Doug Petrie. In a lot of ways it reminds me of last year’s seventh episode “Lie To Me”. Just like last year’s Ford, we are introduced to yet another well-defined single-episode character Gwendolyn Post, who the audience (and Faith) grow very close to. There’s also some real flashes of brilliance from a lot of the actors, particularly Nicholas Brendon and Eliza Dushku.

Buffy 3.8: “Lover’s Walk”, written by Dan Vebber and directed by David Semel

BRILLIANT!!! We’re introduced to season three’s version of Spike (and there really is a different version in each season) and it’s even better than season two’s “School Hard”. I love this episode. I can watch it over and over again. It’s touching, hilarious, and fever-inducing. Spike’s monologue to Buffy and Angel about how they could never be friends is the one of the best things that’s ever been written for the show (wish I knew whether it was Futurama’s hilarious Dan Vebber or Joss Whedon that actually wrote it).

Buffy 3.9: “The Wish”, written by Marti Noxon and directed by David Greenwalt

Here’s how much I love this episode. I think it’s the best episode of the entire show that Joss didn’t write or direct. But we do get the two next best things in Noxon and Greenwalt. This episode is conceptually brilliant, beautifully filmed, incredibly structured, and has amazing performances by every one of the principle cast members. And we meet Anyanka. She’ll come back I’m pretty sure.

Buffy 3.10: “Amends”, written and directed by Joss Whedon

A very Buffy Christmas. A lot of Buffy fans hate this episode because of the sentimental Christmas spirit ending, but what few choose to remember is that the entire crux of the story is built around one of our main characters, Angel, wanting to kill himself. That’s not sentimental at all. I like this one. It’s great seeing Jenny Calendar again, and we get our first glimpse of the brilliant villain The First.

Buffy 3.11: “Gingerbread”, written by Jane Espenson from a story by Thania St. John and directed by James Whitmore, Jr.

This one bores me. The story is interesting enough, and the metaphors are well handled, but this one always leaves me cold. It starts off great with a wonderful opening scene, but as the witch hunt moves forward, I’m left with an awkward detached feeling. I’ve never figured out why. But whatever. Lots of people really like this episode. Make of that what you will.

Buffy 3.12: “Helpless”, written by David Fury and directed by James A. Contner

Fury’s second episode after last year’s “Go Fish” and he comes up with a wonderful idea in the Cruciamentum and he really pulls off the story with flash, wonder, a healthy dose of darkness, and a beautiful bit of pathos. Zachary Kralik is a cool villain, Quentin Travers is an immediately interesting character, and Giles gets sacked from the Watcher’s Council in a scene of wonderful clarity. We also get one of Sarah Michelle Gellar’s best performances of the year.

Buffy 3.13: “The Zeppo”, written by Dan Vebber and directed by James Whitmore, Jr.

The second of two brilliant episodes by Dan Vebber, this one a fantastic study on the art of perspective. It’s beautifully filmed by Whitmore and contains one of Nick Brendon’s greatest performances. It’s funny and interesting and extremely sexy as well (oooh, that Faith!). I’ve always dug this one. I think it’s really well done. Anyone who came up with the bright idea that they should have shown more of the Scoobys’ fight against the Sisterhood of the Zhe didn’t really get it.

Buffy 3.14: “Bad Girls”, written by Douglas Petrie and directed by Michael Lange

Petrie continues his reign as one of the finest writer’s on the staff, and Eliza Dushku continues her reign as the best actress on the guest cast (and super-hot to boot). This is an interesting character piece about absolute power corrupting absolutely, and we get a bit of development within the Buffy and Faith tandem. We also get to meet the wonderfully funny (and soon to be wonderfully depressing) Wesley, and he proves to be the perfect man to really get Giles into the spotlight, and it’s very much worth it.

Buffy 3.15: “Consequences”, written by Marti Noxon and directed by Michael Gersham

Noxon does a fine job in penning the sequel to Petrie’s prior episode. This one isn’t as good or as effecting but it contains some really nice stuff, including the excellent death of Mr. Trick. We get some nice Willow stuff and we get to see more of the Mayor, which is always a good thing.

Buffy 3.16: “Doppelgangland”, written and directed by Joss Whedon

I like this one because you never see Joss do episodes like this anymore. The closest he’s come in years was “Spin The Bottle” in season four of Angel. This is flat-out hilarious, with an incredible performance from Alyson Hannigan and a surprisingly effecting ending. Good Oz stuff here too. In fact, we get a lot of good stuff from everybody. We’re already starting to see a stylistic difference in Joss’s direction as well. His visual style seems a bit more polished and cinematic.

Buffy 3.17: “Enemies”, written by Douglas Petrie and directed by Michael Gersham

This is pretty mediocre until the end. It kind of slogs along for a while before the complete shattering apart of the status quo with Buffy and Angel’s wonderful deception. We also get another really good performance from Eliza Dushku, constantly making Faith a more interesting character.

Buffy 3.18: “Earshot”, written by Jane Espenson and directed by Regis Kimble

This is my favorite non-Joss episode of the whole show, the aforementioned “The Wish”, besides. It actually hit home for me quite a bit back when I first saw it (all the way in SEPTEMBER, thank you WB), and it still hits me the same way now. That stand-off between Buffy and Jonathan in the clock tower grants us some of the best writing in the history of the show, and really excellent performances from Sarah Michelle Gellar and Danny Strong.

Buffy 3.19: “Choices”, written by David Fury and directed by James A. Contner

I like this one. You’re seeing a lot of that in this season. The cool thing about season three was that, though there were a couple of definite stand-out episodes, the season maintained a very consistent quality level. “Choices” is as good as anything this season. It boasts great performances from the regulars and the guest cast (go Harry Groener!) and puts on display the great dialogue and constantly twisting plotlines this show has become known for.

Buffy 3.20: “The Prom”, written by Marti Noxon and directed by David Solomon

Sure, it’s a bit overly sentimental, but Noxon is so good at that stuff that it doesn’t even matter. Xander buying Cordelia a dress, Angel showing up at the Prom after a great break-up scene, and just the awesome cuteness that emanates from Oz and Willow throughout all still bring tingles to my spine. All of this almost makes up for another lame Noxon monster-of-the-week subplot, this time Tucker Wells’ devil dogs.

Buffy 3.21: “Graduation Day Part One”, written and directed by Joss Whedon

AWESOME! I love the “Graduation Day” double-parter. I think it was handled wonderfully and it brought the season to an explosive end (literally and figuratively). In this one we get the Buffy/Faith fight, which completely tears apart everything we’ve seen this year between them. In fact, we get a lot of good stuff in this episode, not the least of which is a great cliffhanger. And we hung. For a LONG time.

Buffy 3.22: “Graduation Day Part Two”, written and directed by Joss Whedon

I’ll never forget how pissed off I was at the world (particularly the WB) when this episode was pushed off until the end of July. I waited. Forever, it seemed. Was it worth it? Of course it was. This episode is the end of act one of the Buffy saga. High school is over. And this episode ends it how it should have been ended. In a flood of tears and hellfire. Because that’s all high school really is in a nutshell. And the Scooby Gang survived.

Daniel Erenberg lives in a gothic-looking house in a suburb of Long Island shrouded by trees and darkness. His backyard is so overrun with shrubbery that he can't plant flowers in the soil. He's penned articles for numerous magazines (and a couple of websites for free). Currently, he's writing his first novel, entitled People That I've Long Since Forgotten. He's also written two plays, Little Room and Dystopia and a screenplay called Youth Or Consequence. He lives a fairly happy life alone except for the mind-numbing loneliness he feels on occasion. If you’re a beautiful woman that’s fallen in love with Daniel, or you just want to talk Buffy with him, you can contact Daniel at
Latest Comments

Hey everybody. I thought about my last post I think there might some misunderstanding about the Buffy would not have run him through with the sword comment. I know she did but here's the issue I was trying to get across to all of you. Buffy didn't know Willow was trying to restore Angel(us)'s soul. What if she had known? Here's where the above commnet comes in. If she had known what Willow was really doing, I think her mind set would have went from I've got to kill Angelus to I still have a chance to get Angel(us) back. I know some people don't want to admit this but I honestly think she would have avoided killing him if she knew. What would that have meant to her friends and everybody else? A chance she would have failed and been killed. Things had already been bad enough because she slept with him and yes, I know she didn't know about the curse but it doesn't change the fact it happened. Considering her age at the time yes, I had issues with it. Those of you that have read my views on this subject know what they are. As it was, he still managed to open Acatha(not sure I'm spelling it right). That's the reason she ran him through with the sword. Not because she WANTED to but because she had to. I see a difference. Considering WHAT she was fighting, what is wrong with that picture? Willow, an inexperienced witch at that point. What if it had backfired, aka didn't work the first time, then what? What if Spike hadn't been there keeping Dru busy? What if he hadn't helped her and she had to deal with BOTH Dru and Angelus? How long do you think she would have lasted? She took too dam long to make a decision I thought. She wasn't thinking with him. That's the problem I had with that situation. They got extremely lucky with Angelus. It could have easily gone the other way. They could have lost.

Posted by: jp on August 25, 2004 11:56 PM

Hey Jill. Read your post. Those are the things that bothered me about the B/A relationship. She was so young and so reckless in her judgement with Angel(us) and some thought that was romantic. Sorry but I just couldn't see it that way. The when you kiss me I want to die comment of hers. Come on. She was 16. First off, they knew about the Angelus identity the BEGINNING of season 2 but yet there was little if any ADULT interference. Giles, being her watcher, in particular. Secondly, she took her time making the decision Angelus had to be destroyed. In the meantime two people lost their lives and her watcher is nearly tortured to death. Thirdly, I tend to think if Buffy knew what Willow was really doing she would not have run him through with the sword which I have no doubt would have cost her her life. Just a thought. Along comes season 3 and she's going behind their backs seing him KNOWING what could happen if she got too touchy feely and that did bother me. Some people will say but she didn't stake Spike in season seven in "Sleeper" and that's true but there's a, I think, important difference. Spike didn't realize what he was doing, Angelus on the other hand knew exactly what he was doing. HE was in control, Spike wasn't in control in season seven. His fragile emotional state made him vulnerable. Angelus didn't have that excuse. I can say this about Spike. He never hid what he is from her. Quote, "You know what I am, you always have, but you come to me all the same." I can't say that about Angel(us). Spike, I think was always more honest with her
than Angel(us) ever was. Angel(us) deceived her about his true identity in the beginning. She found out WHAT he is by accident. Something else about the B/A infatuation. Not trying to offend anyone with the infatuation comment but that's how I saw it so I'm not going to call it anything else. I realize some people aren't going to agree with my opinion but that's o.k. Disagreement is to be expected.

Posted by: jp on August 24, 2004 11:30 PM

Beth, everybody who says that Xander lied because of jealousy makes me ANGRY. That's bullshit.

If he hadn't lied, Angelus would have KILLED Buffy.

And about Buffy's emotional termoil? She fucking protected a KILLER! Someone who wanted to put the entire humanity into HELL. She so much wanted to kill Angelus in Passion huh? She didn't even bring a STAKE with her to kill him. Kendra had to give her Mr. Pointy to let her do her job. It was INSANE to use the spell as a tactic to defeat Angelus. And she has proved time after time she couldn't defeat Angelus, because everytime she had an excuse not to kill him.

Ensouling Angel was a crime! It's a curse created for VENGEANCE. It was INSANE to let an unexperienced witch perform such a dangerous black magic spell. One which opened the door for Willow which couldn't be closed again.
Angel suffered in HELL because of this spell. It was the price HE had to pay. Cause that's how black magic works.

And even when you totally disagree with this, you still forget one big huge factor in the equation of Xander's thoughts: Willow. Xander loves Willow more than Buffy. Always has and always will. Willow is so much more important than Buffy and Angel in his life that he could actually bring her back in Grave. Especially in Becoming II, where he had brought her out of her come by his confession. He has killed a girl he loved (the mummy) to protect Willow. Without a moments thought. Willow is to him what Dawn is to Buffy and even more. And you really think he would betray her for jealousy or his hatred to Angel? Because that's what he did, he betrayed Willow, not Buffy.

Xander is NOT a sod. He risked his friendship with both Buffy and Willow to protect Buffy from Angelus.

Posted by: Jill on August 22, 2004 08:41 PM

I just wanted to say, that my fav season is S3. I just have seen Homecoming Queen, Revelations, Lovers walk, The Wish again in four years. Lovers walk: Spike at his best. The Wish: Anyanka was actually scary and has a demonic voice. Totally different compared to her demonic self in S6/S7. Willow/Angel fantastic! Giles=Super. And how much does vampXander like on Spike? Or VampXander/vampWillow on Spike/Dru?

Posted by: Jane on August 22, 2004 06:41 PM

Hope you guys are all joining us under "The Freshman"!!!

Posted by: Johanne on August 19, 2004 06:57 PM
Full list of comments (426) »

Post a comment

Email Address:



Remember info?

In Association with
Privacy Policy | Copyright © 1999-2004 All rights reserved.
"Buffy The Vampire Slayer" TM and © (or copyright) Fox and its related entities. All rights reserved. Any reproduction, duplication or distribution of these materials in any form is expressly prohibited. This web site, its operators and any content on this site relating to "Buffy The Vampire Slayer" are not authorized by Fox.
Home | Reviews | Articles | Buffy Episode List | Angel Episode List | Trailers/Promos | Spoilers | Official Buffy Site | Videos, DVD's | Advertise on | Buffy Merchandise | Search | Join Slayage The Mailing List | Contact is free to use, but not free to run. All donations are appreciated.
Make payments with PayPal - it's fast, free and secure!
Show your to or if you buy this stuff through the site it helps out with running costs:

anything from blackstar, including:
NEW DESIGNS! t-shirts, mugs, mousepads. Got a suggestion?
Syndicate articles (XML)
Syndicate reviews (XML)
anything from amazon, including:
NS, DS, KM, VL, CF, ES, SR, AF, SJ, CB, AA, JH, RG, LH, GF, DK, EC, LM, SH, CK, AE, EB, XW, DB, MC, MR in other languages
Italiano, Deutsch, Espanol, Francais, Português